Articles

General

What Children's Answers Reveal About Media Trust

What Children's Answers Reveal About Media Trust by Dr. Sam Goldstein

From the Desk of Dr. Sam Goldstein

From Depth to Doubt in a Changing Media World

Key Takeaways

  • Kids now judge media by trust, not just content.
  • Awareness of bias is rising but often lacks real understanding.
  • Media literacy must teach judgment, not just doubt.

Not long ago, a question on a widely used IQ test for children asked something that now feels almost quaint: Why might a newspaper be a better source of information than television? The "correct" answers reflected the media environment of the time. Newspapers, students were expected to say, offered more depth, covered local news, and even included comics. These responses assumed a world in which the key distinction between media was quantity and type of content. Information was scarce enough that the ability to provide more of it in more detail, more pages, and more sections signaled superiority.

Today, however, when educators revisit similar questions, they encounter a strikingly different kind of answer. Many children now say television is worse because it "lies" or is "biased." The shift is subtle but profound. It is no longer about how much information a medium provides, but about whether that information can be trusted at all.

From Information Scarcity to Information Skepticism

In earlier media environments, children were taught to think of news as relatively stable and authoritative. Newspapers were tangible, edited, and structured. Television, though more immediate, was still part of a limited ecosystem of professional journalism. Research from media literacy scholars shows that children historically evaluated credibility based on formal cues such as presentation quality or institutional authority, rather than questioning underlying bias (Flanagin & Metzger, 2010).

But the digital era has fundamentally altered that landscape. Children are now exposed to a constant stream of information across platforms including television, social media, streaming video, and online news. With this abundance comes a new cognitive task: filtering not just for relevance, but for truthfulness. Studies indicate that even young people are increasingly aware that media can be shaped by agendas, ownership, and framing (Ashley, Poepsel, & Willis, 2010). This awareness has led to a rise in generalized skepticism, where children may assume bias even when they lack the tools to analyze it precisely.

The Rise of "Bias" as a Default Explanation

One of the most striking findings in recent research is how readily children invoke the concept of bias. In surveys of young audiences, many express concerns about whether news is "true" or "trustworthy," with some reporting low levels of confidence in traditional media (Notley, Dezuanni, & Howden, 2017). Over the last 20 years, media bias, misinformation, and "fake news" have become increasingly dominant in public discussions about the news. Children learn about bias from their parents, teachers, and the media around them. Therefore, when children hear "bias," they may use the term as a catchphrase for any reason when they don't understand the concept completely. Research about the media shows that conversations about bias can affect how an individual interprets the news and can make individuals more likely to see bias where there is no bias (Tully, Vraga, and Smithson 2020).

Children may come to an incomplete conclusion about the media, that it is not entirely objective. Seeing this new emphasis on media bias may appear to be positive because an understanding of media bias is an important part of media literacy. For years, educational programs have tried to help students analyze different media sources, examine the way the media is framed, and understand how ownership and a point of view can affect the news (Buckingham et al. 2005). Despite the attempt to promote media literacy, researchers warn that this newfound understanding of media bias is often interpreted as being automatically disbelieved. When children automatically accept as true that "the media lies," they may demonstrate an understanding of bias without understanding the nuances that exist within opinions about the media. The media literacy research shows that true media literacy includes not only the ability to recognize bias, but also to understand the varying degrees of reliability and to measure the evidence being used to support an opinion about the media (Hobbs 2017). In other words, the goal is not to distrust everything, but to develop calibrated trust, knowing when to question, when to verify, and when to accept credible information.

Television as Symbol, Not Just Medium

Interestingly, when children say television "lies," they are often not making a technical critique of broadcast journalism. Instead, television has become a symbol, a stand-in for mass media, authority, or even "the system." In the past, television was thought of as speedy and somewhat empty compared to newspapers. Nowadays, TV is characterized by sensationalism, opinion-based material, or politicized agendas. The way children will respond to the culture of television will be through cultural coding, not through direct experiences of the content of specific television shows. On the other hand, newspapers are not the primary news source anymore. Most children don't have direct interactions with print newspapers. Instead of assessing legitimate news sources based on real usage experiences, their ideas of news are developed mostly through the second-hand narratives regarding legitimacy.

What This Change Means

The shift from "newspapers have more detail" to "television lies" reveals a deeper transformation in how children think. It signals a move from content-based evaluation to epistemic evaluation; from asking what is there? to asking what is true? This is, in many ways, a more sophisticated question. It reflects an understanding that information is constructed, not just delivered. But it also introduces new challenges. Without sufficient guidance, children may struggle to differentiate between healthy skepticism and blanket distrust. The implication for educators and parents is clear: teaching media literacy today requires more than pointing out bias. It requires helping children understand how bias operates, how to verify claims, and how to weigh competing sources.

A New Kind of Intelligence

If the old IQ test measured a child's ability to recognize informational advantages of depth, variety, locality, today's equivalent question would measure something else entirely: the ability to navigate trust in a complex media ecosystem. In that sense, the "wrong" answers children give today are not entirely wrong. They are evidence of a world in which the central problem is no longer access to information, but confidence in its reliability. The challenge now is to refine that instinct. To move from "the media lies" to "how can I tell what's true?" That may be a harder question but it is also a more important one. ◆

References

Ashley, S., Poepsel, M., & Willis, E. (2010). Media literacy and news credibility: Does knowledge of media ownership increase skepticism in news consumers? Journal of Media Literacy Education, 2(1), 37–46. https://digitalcommons.uri.edu/jmle/vol2/iss1/3/

Buckingham, D., Banaji, S., Carr, D., Cranmer, S., & Willett, R. (2005). The media literacy of children and young people: A review of the research literature. Ofcom. https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10000145/

Flanagin, A. J., & Metzger, M. J. (2010). Kids and credibility: An empirical examination of youth, digital media use, and information credibility. MIT Press. https://library.oapen.org/handle/20.500.12657/26070

Hobbs, R. (2017). Measuring the digital and media literacy competencies of children and teens. In F. C. Blumberg & P. J. Brooks (Eds.), Cognitive development in digital contexts (pp. 253–274). Elsevier. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128094815000134

Notley, T., Dezuanni, M., & Howden, S. (2017). News and Australian children: How young people access, perceive and are affected by the news. Western Sydney University. https://researchers.westernsydney.edu.au/en/publications/news-and-australian-children-how-young-people-access-perceive-and/

Tully, M., Vraga, E. K., & Smithson, A. B. (2020). News media literacy, perceptions of bias, and interpretation of news. Journalism, 21(2), 209–226. https://doi.org/10.1177/1464884918805262